untitled
reproduced from an August 2, 2002 article from the
Ontario Ministry of Citizenship, Culture and Recreation

The Conservation and Maintenance of Storefronts

This Conservation Note can help storeowners, tenants, LACACs and building professionals in conserving and maintaining their historic commercial properties. This guide provides information on the components of a storefront and gives methods of maintaining the building before deterioration problems reach the serious stage.

History of Storefronts

During the Middle Ages, temporary markets were held on the grounds near cathedrals, and people came from great distances to exchange goods and information. At these events, merchants built temporary stalls to display their wares. Eventually, the most successful markets became permanent, and merchants began to build multi-storey structures with a storefront on the ground level, and housing, offices, or storage in the upper storeys. We still use this basic arrangement today.

Northside of Queen Street, St Marys looking east

In Ontario, storefronts are the distinguishing feature of the main streets in our towns. "Main Street" was often part of a transportation route constructed through the wilderness, for incoming settlers. Along this road, commercial buildings were constructed, usually in a cluster at an intersection, which later became the centre of a town. The main street's commercial facades were designed as rows of attached buildings, often in stone or brick, in a similar fashion to storefronts in large cities. The solidity of these two- and three-storey buildings enclosed the street and made it an identifiable and defined space. With concentrations of buildings containing grocery stores, barber shops, clothing stores, hotels, the town hall and the post office, the main street became the heart and soul of the town. In Ontario, many of our main street storefronts date from the middle of the 19th century.

Goals of Good Storefront Design

The storefront is the single most important feature of the commercial facade, visually and socially. A good storefront and its parts perform many functions simultaneously. It attracts attention, provides effective display space, invites pedestrians to window shop, allows natural light into the store, and enhances the rest of the street.

A storefront's ability to perform these functions is dependent on the character of the storefront's individual parts: base panels, display windows, signs, etc. When the parts work together, they provide a coordinated visual presentation.

When the storefronts of adjacent commercial buildings are conserved, a consistent theme develops which visually links the various facades of the street.

Guidelines for conserving storefronts:

  • Where the original storefront remains largely intact, conserve and repair it.
  • Where changes are out of character, probe behind the modern layers to see if anything original remains. In many cases, the authentic elements may still be in place, hidden beneath later alterations.
  • The storefront should be conserved by keeping any of the original building fabric which survives. Replace only the missing features.
  • Documentary evidence such as historic photographs can be used when the original building's fabric has not survived.

Components of Storefront Structure

A commercial facade is usually comprised of three parts: i) the bottom or storefront, from the base panel to the storefront's cornice; ii) the middle facade; and iii) the top, or the building's cornice.

Illustration: Components of storefront structure

Base panel

Function: A base panel -- where the building meets the ground -- provides a strong anchor to the storefront. It also acts as a plinth for the display windows, providing a simple method of placing the display area at an effective viewing height. Base panels also act as kickplates.

Maintenance: For fit and durability, the original base panels are the most practical, and they can be maintained with painting and other periodic repairs. Materials used for replacing base panels should fit in with the rest of the storefront -- and be durable. If wood is used as a replacement, it should be exterior grade, properly sealed, and painted.

Illustration: Base panel

Display Windows

Function: Display windows encourage window shopping and allow the potential customer to view the merchandise on display as well as the inside of the store. They also allow daylight to enter the store and increase the feeling of openness. These windows reduce the barrier between the store and the customer on the sidewalk: the storespace becomes part of the street.

Maintenance: Display windows are important visually and socially. They should not be blocked off or reduced in size. Replacing large display windows with solid walls or smaller windows damages the visual connection along the street, disrupting the effect of a continuous display case. Reducing natural lighting and restricting views may also diminish the attractiveness of the building's interior.

Display window frames are made of wood, metal, copper, or stainless steel. Most original cast-iron and wood frames have stood up well over time and should be maintained. They usually have a better fit, and repairs and maintenance are cheaper than replacement. If the original frames have been lost, they can be replaced with new frames using patterns similar to the original.

Storefront Entries and Floors

Function: The storefront entrance is usually recessed, "pushed in" from the display windows. These recessed entries bring attention to the doorways, while leaving the display windows in a prominent position. Recessed entries contribute important features of depth and shade to the street, and when repeated in adjacent stores, they create one of the important rhythms in a traditional commercial area. And the floor surface of a recessed entry provides an important welcome mat to the customer and contributes to the quality of the greeting.

Illustration: Storefront entry


Maintenance: Original tile and terrazzo floors should be maintained, not only because they are prestigous but also because they are difficult to remove and replace. The most suitable materials for the entrance floor are those which fit in with the storefront, resist the strains of shrinking and expanding, are unaffected by or prevent water penetration, resist deterioration, and offer traction. The most common materials include concrete, terrazo, stone, brick, and tiles.


Storefront Doors

Function: The best storefront doors attempt to impress, through their proportions and materials. The door is often the first contact the customer has with the place of business. The feel, weight, and operation of the front door and its hardware leaves an important impression. Like the display windows, storefront doors with their large panels of glass also provide inviting views into the store, natural light penetration, and an area for an effective but discrete sign. Doors are sometimes provided with brass kickplates.

Maintenance: Like other components of the facade, the doors also reinforce the character of the overall design and the appearance of the building. If the original doors are still in place, they will perform this function. If new doors are needed, choose ones with large glass panels that will harmonize with the existing facade.

Storefront Awnings

Illustration: Storefront awning

Function: Awnings provide a physical extension of the building over the sidewalk. They create a contained and protected space where shoppers can step away from traffic, seek shelter from rain or snow, and examine the displays of the shop inside. They also provide shelter for merchandise displayed on the sidewalk. Awnings can attract positive attention and offer an opportunity for store identification. Signs can be incorporated into the drop flap or valance. Consistency in storefront heights and awning locations reinforce the important patterns of the facades and street wall.

Maintenance: Maintain awnings wherever possible. While awnings may not be critical to every storefront design, they can produce immediate and dramatic results at moderate cost. The colours and patterns should enhance the features of the facade.


Signs

Function: Signs have always played a key role on commercial streets. Today's problems of oversized signs were avoided in the past largely because signs were a local craft. Local signmakers used a limited number of materials, applying known and respected patterns. The result was a visually coordinated and effective commercial area.

Illustration: Shop sign


Signs should not overpower the facade. The scale of facades of main street areas should be geared to pedestrians and slower traffic. Located above the display window(s) and below the storefront's cornice, the sign should harmonize with the rest of the facade and should only span one storefront.


Maintenance: Good signboards can be fabricated from marine exterior plywood. Individual letters applied to or painted on the face of the signboard are, as a rule, more attractive than sign boxes. Lighting should be from an external source such as a spotlight or a floodlight. Although the lettering should reflect the business's image, it should also reflect the overall design and historic period of the storefront.

Storefront Cornice

Function: The traditional storefront cornice clearly caps the storefront and separates it from the middle facade. Together, the storefront cornices of the street often form the strongest and most continuous line on the street, uniting the various buildings.

Maintenance: The most common problem associated with cornices is deterioration, the result of inadequate waterproofing or other deterioration, especially in the flashing and caulking. Periodic inspections, recaulking, and repair will help save this distinctive feature.

The Middle Facade

Function: The middle facade is characterized by a flat wall, largely solid in appearance, with regularly spaced windows cut into it. The size, proportions, spacing, and decorative features of the windows are a major contribution to both the unity of the street and the individual facades.

Maintenance: The original masonry should be maintained and conserved. Exterior cladding should be avoided; it may create moisture problems in the wall and detract from the historical appearance of the facade. If the masonry has been painted, various options are available to enhance the building, including cleaning or repainting in a compatible colour. If the masonry has never been painted, cleaning is preferable to painting.

Windows should be maintained; their openings should not be boarded up. The windows should be checked periodically, particularly the sills -- both the upper and lower surfaces -- and anywhere else water collects. Caulking, painting, and proper drainage will give the windows long-term service. If a window has deteriorated so badly that it cannot be repaired, try to find a replacement that resembles the original, as closely as possible, in appearance and material.

Building Cornice

Function: Usually a decorative cornice or pitched roof (or both) top off a typical facade. These features play the important role of visually capping off the face of the building. If the cornice is removed, a building looks incomplete or less substantial.

Maintenance: Cornices can be made from brick, stone, wood, pressed metal, terra cotta, or ceramic tiles. The most common problem associated with cornices is deterioration as a result of inadequate or deteriorating weather-proofing, especially in the flashing and caulking. Periodic inspections, recaulking, and repairs will save these features. If the existing cornice is in bad shape, repair is generally cheaper and preferable to replacement.

Paint

Function: Paint provides two functions: protection of the building material from weathering and rot, and the provision of colour and a visible expression of individuality. Colours help define the specific look of the commercial area and help link facades together visually. Careful use of colours can also unify the components within a facade. With thoughtful consideration for colour schemes, the results of repainting a facade are immediate, dramatic, and relatively inexpensive.

Maintenance: Paint is the first line of defence against decay, and evidence of deterioration should be checked year round. For historic authenticity, the original colours of the facade should be used whenever possible, and they can be discovered by scraping the subsequent layers of paint from representative areas of the facade. Your LACAC might be able to assist with paint scrapes and offer colour suggestions appropriate to specific buildings. Paint suppliers have historic colour charts and are able to assist in the selection of suitable colours and type of paint.

Conclusion

If main streets are the heart and soul of our communities, it is in all our interests to maintain and conserve our historic storefronts. Continuous, long-term maintenance is a cheaper and more manageable strategy than wholesale restoration of buildings. Conservation and maintenance of our storefronts means greater heritage awareness, more profitable businesses, as well as healthier and prosperous communities.

For further reading on store fronts, refer to: Well Preserved, by Mark Fram, Ontario Heritage Foundation, Boston Mills Press, 1988.

For more information, please call the Heritage Properties and Museums Programs Unit at (416) 314-7137.


This publication is not copyrighted and can be reproduced without penalty. Normal procedures for credit to the author and the Ministry of Citizenship, Culture and Recreation are appreciated.

 
112 Queen St.   Gregory Block
115 Queen St.   McDonald Block
142 Queen St.   Guest Block
145 Queen St.   Robert Eaton
150 Queen St.   Grand Central Hotel
153 Queen St.   Bennett Block
159 Queen St.   McIntyre Store
 
Stores Not Designated
as Heritage Properties

L A Ball Furniture
W F Douglas Wallpaper
Hubbard Pharmacy
Anstett Jewellers
Dunny's Source for Sports

Making the Case for
Heritage Designation to a
Property Owner

Web Hosting · Blog · Guestbooks · Message Forums · Mailing Lists
Allwebco Web Templates · Build your own toolbar · Site Building Articles · Audio, Fonts, Clipart
powered by a free webtools company bravenet.com